"Wrong return address" when someone signs in. The address your site asked Key to send people back to isn't in the app's Return addresses. Add the exact one, including https:// and any path.
The Install box says the publishable key is "none yet". The app has no live publishable key: its only one was revoked. Make one under Keys.
A member never gets the email. Ask them to check their spam folder and to use the newest email only, since a new email replaces the old code. If it still doesn't come, write to hello@superintelligentkey.com.
A member opened the link on their phone but started on a computer. The link works only in the browser that started the sign-in. Type the 6-digit code into the first window instead.
"Your sign-in is from before the dashboard needed this." Sign out of the dashboard and sign in again, then try once more.
A plan change hasn't reached a member. It arrives the next time their sign-in refreshes, within 15 minutes.